The Town of Newburgh wraps around the City of Newburgh on the north and west and runs from the Hudson out to Orange Lake. It is a separate municipality from the City, with its own Town Board, its own code and its own rental rules, and it covers communities such as Balmville, Gardnertown and Orange Lake. Only about one household in five rents here, and rents run well above the county median, so Town rentals are a small, well-paid market where condition and pricing decide how fast a unit leases. Our local, family-owned team has managed Hudson Valley rentals since 2005 and now oversees more than 1,000 units.
Property management services for Town of Newburgh rentals
-
Tenant screening and placement: credit, income, rental-history and background checks, applied the same way to every applicant. New York caps the applicant screening fee at $20, and we follow that rule.
-
Rent pricing: set from current Town of Newburgh comparables, kept separate from City of Newburgh rents, and reviewed at every renewal.
-
Marketing and showings: listings on our rental search page and the major rental sites.
-
Leases and renewals: New York-compliant leases, renewals and rent-increase notices on the 30/60/90-day schedule.
-
Rent collection and accounting: online payments, an owner portal, monthly statements and year-end reports.
-
Maintenance coordination: with 24/7 emergency maintenance availability, for single-family homes, two-families and small apartment buildings across the Town.
-
Relocation support: full management for owners who move away and need a local manager.
-
Evictions: handled when a tenancy fails, coordinated with your attorney.
-
See the full menu on our services page or compare plans on full-service management.

Who rents in the Town of Newburgh
About 20% of Town of Newburgh households rent (roughly 2,350 renting households against 9,300 owners), compared with 32% across Orange County. The Town's median gross rent is about $2,159 a month (includes utilities; covers every rental unit), well above the county's $1,680. Among renters paying cash rent, about 60% pay $2,000 or more (28% pay $2,500 or more), 18% pay $1,500 to $1,999, 17% pay $1,000 to $1,499 and fewer than 5% pay under $1,000. The rental stock is mostly small buildings: about 30% of renters live in single-family homes, 15% in two-families, 22% in three- or four-unit buildings, 14% in buildings of five to nine units and 18% in buildings of ten or more. About 43% of renters live in two-bedroom homes and 29% in three bedrooms or more. The median renting household earns about $102,000, nearly twice the county's renter median of about $55,000, and about 44% of renters spend 30% or more of income on rent (57% countywide). About half of the Town's homes were built before 1980. Among the larger communities, Orange Lake has about 520 renting households, Gardnertown about 300 and Balmville about 260. For owners, that means tenants with strong incomes and high expectations: a well-kept unit priced off Town comparables, not City ones, is what leases quickly.
Nearby towns we manage: City of Newburgh · New Windsor · Montgomery · Marlboro · Plattekill
How we can help
Buying a home or small multifamily in the Town of Newburgh? Email the address to christopher@integritypropertymgt.com before you close and we'll reply in writing with a rental review: realistic rent against Town comparables, whether it is in the Town or the City, and what it would cost to run. Start with a quote.
Thinking about switching managers? We take over occupied properties. Full-service management is 5-10% of monthly rent, and your first 60 days are our free trial.
Run your own rentals? Accounting-only support is 1.5% and back-office support is 3.5%. See the bookkeeping page or call (845) 512-7368.
Town of Newburgh landlord rules to know in 2026
The Town does not license rentals the way the City does. The Town of Newburgh Code (current through December 8, 2025, with no newer laws pending) has no rental license, rental permit or rental registry chapter. That is the biggest difference from the City of Newburgh, which licenses every rental under City Code Chapter 240. Don't assume a Town property follows City rules, or the other way around.
Apartment buildings get inspected on a schedule. Under Town Code § 71-12, the Code Compliance Department inspects multiple dwellings for fire safety and property maintenance at least once every 36 months. It can also inspect any dwelling unit when the owner asks or when it receives a written complaint or other reliable information about a code violation. If it finds a violation, § 71-18 lets it issue a written order to fix it, normally within 30 days.
Conversions need a permit and a certificate. Town Code § 71-8 requires a certificate of occupancy or certificate of compliance for any work done under a building permit and for any building, or part of one, converted to a different use or occupancy. Turning a basement, garage or single-family into rental space is a permit job, not a lease job.
Accessory apartments are allowed, with conditions. Town Code § 185-38 permits one accessory apartment per lot in residence districts (and in existing single-family homes in the B and IB districts). The owner must live on the property, the main house must be at least five years old, and the apartment can have no more than two bedrooms, must be 450 to 700 square feet and can house up to five residents. It needs one extra off-street parking space and its own building permit and certificate of occupancy. Over 700 square feet, the building counts as a two-family.
Short-term rentals pay a 5% Town occupancy tax. The Town Code has no short-term rental permit chapter, but Chapter 166, Article IX taxes "short term" and "vacation" rentals as tourist facilities. A 5% tax applies to stays shorter than 90 consecutive days. The operator must register with the Town Supervisor within three days of starting, display the certificate of authority, and file a return within 20 days after each quarter ending in March, June, September and December. Booking platforms can register and file for their hosts. Late filing or payment adds a 5% penalty plus 1% interest for each month of delay after the first. Check zoning with the Town's Code Compliance Department before you list.
Good Cause Eviction: the City opted in, the Town has not. DHCR's Good Cause notice lists the City of Newburgh among the municipalities that opted in as of May 4, 2026 (with a 345% fair market rent exemption). The Town of Newburgh is not on that list. Outside New York City, the Good Cause law applies only where a municipality opts in, so Town rentals are not covered unless the Town adopts it later.
Ask the county about the lead rental registry. The state's Lead Rental Registry covers pre-1980 buildings with two or more units in 25 communities of concern, and it lists "Newburgh" without saying whether that means the City, the Town or both. About half of the Town's homes predate 1980, so if you own an older two-family or apartment building in the Town, confirm its status with the Orange County Department of Health before you assume it is exempt. Federal lead-paint disclosure applies to every pre-1978 rental.
Check the municipality, not the mailing address. Town and City properties both carry Newburgh mailing addresses; the Town's own Code Compliance office is at a Newburgh, NY 12550 address. Confirm which municipality a property is in before you price it or file anything. For City properties, see our City of Newburgh page.
State rules apply everywhere. Security deposits are capped at one month's rent, an itemized statement is due within 14 days of move-out, and late fees can't start until rent is more than five days late and are capped at $50 or 5%, whichever is less.
This information is general and not legal advice. Rules change often; consult an attorney or the municipality for your specific situation.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a rental license in the Town of Newburgh?
We found no Town rental license or rental registry. The Town Code on eCode360 (current through December 8, 2025, with no newer laws pending) has no rental licensing or registration chapter. That is the main difference from the City of Newburgh, which licenses every rental under City Code Chapter 240. Town rules still apply: a building permit and a certificate of occupancy or compliance for new work and conversions, and fire safety and property maintenance inspections of multiple dwellings at least once every 36 months.
How do I know if a property is in the Town or the City of Newburgh?
Don't go by the mailing address. Both use Newburgh addresses; the Town's own Code Compliance office has a Newburgh, NY 12550 address. Check the property tax bill or the county parcel record to see which municipality the property is in, because the City and the Town have different rental laws.
Does Good Cause Eviction apply in the Town of Newburgh?
Not as of DHCR's latest list. The City of Newburgh has opted in, but the Town of Newburgh was not on DHCR's list of opted-in municipalities as of May 4, 2026. Outside New York City, the Good Cause law covers only municipalities that opt in, so check DHCR's current list before relying on this.
Can I run an Airbnb in the Town of Newburgh?
The Town Code has no short-term rental permit chapter, but short-term and vacation rentals are taxed. Chapter 166, Article IX puts a 5% occupancy tax on stays shorter than 90 consecutive days. The operator must register with the Town Supervisor within three days of starting, display the certificate of authority and file quarterly returns. Booking platforms may register and file for their hosts. Confirm zoning with the Town's Code Compliance Department before listing.
Can I add an accessory apartment to my house in the Town of Newburgh?
Possibly. Under Town Code § 185-38 the owner must live on the property, the main house must be at least five years old, and the apartment can have no more than two bedrooms, 450 to 700 square feet and up to five residents. Only one is allowed per lot, it needs an extra off-street parking space, and it needs its own building permit and certificate of occupancy. Above 700 square feet the building is treated as a two-family.
Is the Town of Newburgh in the state lead rental registry?
The Department of Health lists "Newburgh" among its 25 communities of concern but does not say whether that means the City, the Town or both. If you own a pre-1980 building with two or more units in the Town, ask the Orange County Department of Health, which runs the registry locally, before you assume it is exempt.
What do rentals go for in the Town of Newburgh?
Census estimates (ACS 2020-2024) put the Town's median gross rent at about $2,159 a month, including utilities, against about $1,680 for Orange County. About 60% of Town renters paying cash rent pay $2,000 or more, and about 28% pay $2,500 or more. Rent depends on size, condition and location.
How much does property management cost in the Town of Newburgh?
Full-service management is 5–10% of monthly rent, depending on the property type, the number of units and the services you need. Accounting-only support is 1.5% and back-office support is 3.5%. Every new client starts with our 60-Day Free Trial.







