New Windsor runs along the Hudson next to the City of Newburgh, with about 27,800 residents and hamlets such as Vails Gate, Little Britain and Rock Tavern. Roughly one household in four rents, so rentals here are a smaller, steadier market than in the city next door, and condition, pricing and a clean lease matter more than speed. Our local, family-owned team has managed Hudson Valley rentals since 2005 and now oversees more than 1,000 units.
Property management services for New Windsor rentals
-
Tenant screening and placement: credit, income, rental-history and background checks, applied the same way to every applicant. New York caps the applicant screening fee at $20, and we follow that rule.
-
Rent pricing: set from current New Windsor comparables, not county averages, and reviewed at every renewal.
-
Marketing and showings: listings on our rental search page and the major rental sites.
-
Leases and renewals: New York-compliant leases, renewals and rent-increase notices on the 30/60/90-day schedule.
-
Rent collection and accounting: online payments, an owner portal, monthly statements and year-end reports.
-
Maintenance coordination with 24/7 emergency maintenance availability, for older houses and newer subdivisions alike.
-
Relocation support: full management for owners who move away and need a local manager.
-
Evictions handled when a tenancy fails, coordinated with your attorney.

Who rents in New Windsor
About 27% of Town of New Windsor households rent (roughly 2,940 renting households against 8,040 owners), compared with about 32% across Orange County. The median gross rent was $1,606 a month (includes utilities; covers every rental unit), up from $1,284 in 2015-2019. About a third of rented homes fall in the $1,500 to $1,999 range and about 23% rent for $2,000 or more. The median renting household earned about $53,000. With a smaller rental share and rents that have climbed about 25% in five years, pricing to current comparables and careful screening protect owners more than a fast lease-up does.
Nearby towns we manage: Newburgh · Cornwall · Montgomery · Beacon
How we can help
Buying a house or two-family in New Windsor? Call (845) 512-7368 before you close and we'll review it as a rental: realistic rent, repair exposure and what it would cost to run. Start with a quote.
Thinking about switching managers? We take over occupied properties. Full-service management is 5-10% of monthly rent, and your first 60 days are our free trial.
Run your own rentals? Accounting-only support is 1.5% and back-office support is 3.5%. See the bookkeeping page or call (845) 512-7368.
New Windsor landlord rules to know in 2026
No town rental license or registry. The Town Code has no rental registration or licensing chapter, so New Windsor owners don't need the rental license that the City of Newburgh requires. Rentals still need a valid certificate of occupancy, and the Building Department issues them.
Multiple dwellings are inspected on a schedule. Town Code § 107-11 requires fire-safety and property-maintenance inspections of multiple dwellings at least once every 36 months. Owners and managers should expect an inspection notice and keep exits, alarms and common areas in order.
Short-term rentals: a permit law is proposed. The Town has no short-term-rental code today. The Town Board has proposed a new Chapter 220 that would require a Town permit to run a short-term rental, and it set a public hearing for December 2, 2026 at 7:00 p.m. at Town Hall, 555 Union Avenue. Check the Town's website for the adopted version before you list a home for stays under 30 days.
Good Cause Eviction doesn't apply here. The Town of New Windsor was not on DHCR's list of opt-in municipalities as of May 4, 2026. The City of Newburgh, next door, has opted in, so owners on either side of the line follow different renewal rules.
No lead rental registry. New Windsor isn't one of the 25 communities in the state Lead Rental Registry; the City of Newburgh is. Federal lead-paint disclosure still applies to pre-1978 homes.
State rules apply everywhere. Security deposits are capped at one month's rent, an itemized statement is due within 14 days of move-out, and late fees can't start until rent is more than five days late and are capped at $50 or 5%, whichever is less.
This information is general and not legal advice. Rules change often; consult an attorney or the municipality for your specific situation.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a rental license in New Windsor?
No. The Town Code has no rental license or registry. You do need a valid certificate of occupancy, and multiple dwellings are inspected at least every 36 months. If your property is in the City of Newburgh instead, a city rental license is required.
Does Good Cause Eviction apply in New Windsor?
No. The Town of New Windsor was not on DHCR's opt-in list as of May 4, 2026. Statewide rules on deposits, late fees and notice periods still apply, and we watch for any local opt-in.
What do rentals go for in New Windsor?
Census estimates (ACS 2020-2024) put the Town of New Windsor's median gross rent at about $1,606, which includes utilities. Rent depends on size, condition and location. Request an instant quote or call (845) 512-7368 for an estimate on your address.
Can I run an Airbnb in New Windsor?
The Town has no short-term-rental law yet, but the Town Board has proposed one that would require a permit and set a public hearing for December 2, 2026. Check the Town's website for the adopted rules before you list.
How much does property management cost in New Windsor?
Our management fee is 5-10% of monthly rent, depending on the property type, the number of units and the services you need. Every new New Windsor client starts with our 60-Day Free Trial.
I live outside the area. Can you manage my New Windsor property?
Yes. We act as your local managing agent: screening, rent collection, repairs, inspections and monthly statements, with an emergency line answered 24/7.

